At ShotByShot, we believe the proper way to evaluate short game ability is to measure the average putting distance after the short game shot, and calculate the % of opportunities that are successfully hit to within 5 feet.
Chip/Pitch Shots - How Important?
The answer for any golfer depends on the number of opportunities faced in each round. Long game performance directly affects the number of chip/pitch opportunities because more greens-hit-in-regulation means fewer short game shots – but that’s a topic for another day.
Here are some basic statistics from the ShotByShot database to help put your short game skill in perspective:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/21001/21001a09a2f751e905cfc99677de7851179702db" alt=""
These stats will tell you whether or not your Short Game represents an improvement opportunity, or if your precious practice and lesson time (and $$$) should be spent elsewhere.
For a Complete Analysis of Your Game, go to: http://www.shotbyshot.com/
Peter - I wish more amateurs would review this blog post. You are bang on with more details to determine up and down percentage. For example, a junior golfer said he had a good short game but had putting problems because he was only getting up and down 20% of the time. After using Shot by Shot, he learned that he was only getting the ball inside 5 feet less than 5% of the time. After some practice and rounds, he improved both percentages.
ReplyDeleteSincerely,
Brian Gallant, CPGA, B.Sc.Kin, CAO Coach
BG Golf Academy at FireRock
www.bggolf.ca