Fairways Missed Y.E. Yang's Problem? NOT!

Did anyone hear Johnny Miller comment several times during the recent President's Cup telecast that the reason for Y.E. Yang's lack of visibility lately has been his inability to hit fairways? I did. In fact, I heard him say it several times. The ability to hit fairways is the hallowed traditional measure of golf driving accuracy. But it is also the most one-dimensional and potentially the most misleading of the traditional golf statistics.

Johnny Miller bemoaned the fact that Yang was only hitting 60% of his fairways, and that a tour golfer cannot win tournaments with that kind of performance. What Johnny needs to know is that the PGA Tour average for Fairways Hit is less than 63%, and that Tiger Woods hits just over 64%!

What is the matter with this statistic? Hitting the fairway is, after all, the goal when we stand on the tee of a par 4 or par 5 hole. The problem is that it asks for a simple Yes/No answer to a question that forces us to focus mainly on the Yes. Why? Because conventional wisdom has us believing that ‘Yes, I hit the fairway!’ is the most positive outcome. But think about it – is that really the case? Isn't what happens when we don't hit the fairway so much more impactful on our golf score?

Over the past 18 years ShotByShot.com has analyzed golf performance at every level – including PGA Tour players – and has concluded that hitting or missing fairways is a statistic of limited relevance. Of far greater importance is the character and severity of the miss. Did the ball land just in the light rough, in a bunker, behind a tree (with or without a shot?), disappear in a pond, or worst of all – go lost or OB?

The higher the level of the player’s golf game, the less relevant is the number of fairways hit to improvement or performance. A recent study of performance on the PGA Tour conducted by two professors at Northeastern University in Boston cited the declining importance of driving accuracy due primarily to increasing driving distances. To support this, during his 2007 seven-event winning streak, Tiger Woods hit only 61% of the fairways. In the final event of that streak at Torrey Pines, Tiger hit only 46% of the fairways en route to victory. Of far greater importance was the fact that Tiger’s tee shots resulted in an ERROR in only 2% of his total attempts. (ShotByShot’s definition of ERROR = a penalty, or a shot from which the golfer does not have a normal advancement opportunity.)

In no way do I want to pick on Johnny Miller. I enjoy his insightful and honest commentary - he is arguably the best there is at his job. Further, I had the good fortune of spending some time with him at an LPGA event in the early days of ShotByShot and found him very thoughtful and gracious. I am a fan. That said, his comment exemplifies the pervasive misconceptions that are created by "traditional" golf statistics and why I created something much better in shotbyshot.com. In a future blog, I will delve into some niblicks of truth about what really is to blame for Y. E. Yang's lack of success at the highest level.